Having been brought up by a Catholic mother, while also being instructed in the basics of Protestantism by my father, the season of Lent has always been a time of decision. How shall I observe Lent this year, by giving something up, or by giving of myself? Quite a dilemma and fraught with confusion and a fair share of guilt. As an adult I’ve studied the differing ways these two denominations “do” Lent and discovered both the value, as well as, the pitfalls of “giving up” versus “giving of”.
Pointing a finger squarely at myself, I can honestly admit I have committed each denominations mistakes. As a youngster, pride reared its head if my sacrifice for Lent seemed greater than my best friend’s. The problem of coming out ahead through sacrifice (if I give up chocolate, I might lose a couple of pounds) was and still is present. The difficulties of a basically self-centered, loner-personality are hard to overcome. As an adult in a reformed church I’ve felt slightly smug when giving of myself.
Protestants, I think, underestimate the value of giving something up for Lent. When you forfeit chocolate or TV for Lent, you are aware many times a day of your sacrifice. Each time you long for that cookie you realize how small your offering is compared to Christ’s sacrifice. Each time you wish you could satisfy your habit, you remember God. That is no small thing. The time isn’t meant for wallowing in sin, but in acknowledging the immense love God had for us and how infrequently we return that love or even think of Him.
Giving of ourselves brings us closer to the “what would Jesus do?” question. How can we bring His Kingdom closer, how do we show our love and tolerance for those around us and especially for those who are different from us. But if it’s a one shot deal during the 40 days, is it really effective? If it is a daily “offering” of ourselves for 40 days, that is indeed, a fitting gift to our Lord, but how to accomplish it takes great dedication and thought.
The questions I ask myself, are — What can I do that will bring me a greater awareness of God’s nearness and keep me in His presence? What can I offer to show my love for Him? How can I bring about His Kingdom in some small way?
There is no best way to observe Lent. Each of the two ways, and there are many others, I’m sure, are valid, if done with love. Isn’t that what Lent, faith and Christianity all boil down to; God’s tremendous love for us and our half-hearted attempts to love Him back? So, standing before God’s love, as if it were the world’s tallest mountain, I come with a tiny pebble, no bigger than a grain of sand, and I offer it to Him in complete humility, knowing He sees it and understands. It’s the only thing I can do.

